Holding Grief and Joy: When Two Truths Exist in One Heart
Life often leads us into moments that seem to hold two opposite emotions at once—grief over what could’ve been, and joy over what is.
It’s a strange place to stand, isn’t it? You find yourself smiling through tears, grateful yet aching, celebrating while something deep inside still longs for a different story.
Maybe it’s the birthday of someone you’ve lost, or a season where blessings surround you, yet the quiet sting of something or someone that hurt you lingers. We tend to think we must pick one emotion—either joy or sorrow—but Scripture shows us that both can live within the same heart.
Jesus Wept and Rejoiced
Jesus Himself modeled this beautifully. When His friend Lazarus died, He wept (John 11:35). Even though He knew resurrection was moments away, He didn’t rush past the pain or silence the tears. Instead, He entered into the grief, honoring the weight of loss, and in the same breath, brought forth joy.
This moment reveals the heart of our Savior. Jesus doesn’t bypass sorrow—He sanctifies it. He allows us to hold both disappointment and joy because both can be holy. Grief honors love, hope, and what was once deeply adored. Joy honors God’s faithfulness and His presence in the midst of it all.
The Biblical Paradox of “Sorrowful, Yet Always Rejoicing”
Paul captures this tension perfectly in 2 Corinthians 6:10 when he writes that we are “sorrowful, yet always rejoicing.” This paradox is the rhythm of a heart that trusts God in every season—one that can mourn what was lost while still seeing the goodness that remains.
In biblical times, lament was not seen as a lack of faith but as a form of it. The psalms are full of honest cries to God that end in worship. True faith doesn’t deny pain; it invites God into it.
When we learn to hold both emotions, we reflect the fullness of God’s design for our humanity—a heart that feels deeply, yet hopes fiercely.
Holding Both with Open Hands
If you’re standing in that space today, feeling the ache of “what could’ve been” even as you glimpse the beauty in “what is,” know this: God is not asking you to choose one emotion. He is big enough to hold both with you.
Let your tears and your joy rise together as an offering. Both are worship. Both declare, “God, You are good, even here.”
As Romans 12:15 reminds us, “Rejoice with those who rejoice; mourn with those who mourn.” We were made for this—community, compassion, and a faith that feels both the weight of grief and the warmth of joy.
Prayer
Lord, thank You for being near to the brokenhearted and the joyful all at once. Help me see Your goodness even in the tension. Teach me to hold both with open hands, trusting that You make beauty from every part of my story. In Jesus’ name, Amen.
Meet the Author
Amy Max
Amy is a Chicago native, wife of 20 years to her favorite pastor, and mother of three awesome kids (ages 16, 13, 10). She loves encouraging women to see God’s hand in everyday moments of life. Amy speaks at women’s events, sharing faith-filled insights to help others walk boldly with God. In-between family adventures, cheering on her kid’s passions, and serving in the local church, she loves to point others to Jesus and the hope we have in Him.
Connect with here on Instagram here.
